A Murderer In Court; He Just Looked At Her

Last Updated by Kealey Bultena on

I work in news, and Friday’s assignment involved a court hearing for a man convicted of brutally murdering a correctional officer during a prison escape attempt. He’s been sentenced to death and had, until this point, filed appeals to delay his execution. The news is straight-forward fact to inform audiences. That doesn’t mean our experience collecting it is as simple.

I heard jingling. It was a high tone – like a tinny sound, not quite as full as when someone clinks their keys together but clearly metal on metal. The sound sliced through the quiet courtroom. It was coming from Rodney Berget. He was jingling the metal of his shackles.

Rodney Berget’s hearing was scheduled for 8:15 a.m., but you can’t tell what time it is from the courtroom. It doesn’t have any windows. By the time I got through security and upstairs, Berget was already in a chair next to his lawyer. It’s warmer than you’d think in that room.

Friday’s court appearance is the latest in a saga spanning more than five years. I remember my news role in 2011 as a prison went into lockdown, as we learned inmates had tried to escape, as we heard a man was dead, and as we saw the surveillance images taken minutes after he was attacked. I produced the newscasts that Saturday that lead with correctional officer Ron “RJ” Johnson’s funeral service. I remember hearing the wails of his widow, and I distinctly recall knowing that I would never put that sound on the air. It just wasn’t fair – to her or to anyone else.

When I got to the courtroom Friday, I slid into one of the hard, wooden benches. They’re like church pews. They’re worn smooth, made of light-colored wood, and they creak a little when you move a certain way. Two sets go back to the wall opposite the judge with an aisle in between. I always wonder, is this like weddings? Am I supposed to sit on one side or the other? I’m not trying to show my allegiance to anyone; do people think of it like that? I sat on the left side, behind the defense, three rows from the front.

I’ve handled much of the news out of this case. I followed the trial and sentencing with rapt attention. I wrote about appeals or lack of appeals. I toured the penitentiary before Eric Robert, Berget’s partner in the escape attempt and killing, was executed. I walked through the holding area where he’d spend his final time. The image of the execution chamber that you see with our stories about the death penalty? That’s mine. I took that picture. I stayed up with our team the night Robert died into the next day, and we left after 3 a.m.

Friday Berget swayed in his rolly chair. His more-white-than-gray hair was pulled into a tight ponytail at the base of his head. The frizz was long enough to cover part of the writing on the back of his bright orange prison jumpsuit. More jingling. The shackles.

Once the judge arrived, Berget answered questions. The judge wanted to make sure he knows that stopping the appeal process is a finite decision, that he can’t bring it up again, and that he will be executed. The inmate said “yes” to clarify he understood. His lawyer spoke against the move, and Berget talked about how he doesn’t want his defense attorney to fight for an investigation into his intellectual capacity. He said he won’t go so far as to tell him what to do, what to believe, what his duty is as an attorney.  

When the court recessed, an officer lead Berget across the courtroom. That’s when the murdered man’s widow yelled at him. Some small whispers and sighs had come from that bench during the hearing, but what she said here was intentionally audible and pointed. I wrote it down exactly as I heard it. She said, “Tell your lawyer to stop! Just tell him to stop!” Berget looked at her. I don’t know what I saw. He didn’t express joy, but he wasn’t sad. He didn’t mock her, but I didn’t read any regret or pity on his face. It wasn’t threatening or menacing, but it wasn’t comforting. He just... looked at her. Then he disappeared through the door.

This is one moment that lingers in time. I don’t have a photo; I couldn’t take a camera in the courtroom. It doesn’t matter. I can feel that frozen gaze on his face as I hear her shouting at him, and I know that’s what will flash into my mind as I follow this through to its eventual end. News job or not, I’m compelled to follow this to the end.

subscribe to sdpb email updates food and cooking banner image learning blog link living blog link news and information blog link science and technology blog link sports blog link image

The Latest From SDPB Radio News

Women, Supporters March In Rapid City To Assert Women's Rights As Human Rights

On Saturday South Dakotans joined millions of people across the world for a one-day rally. The Women's March on...

Suzan Nolan in D.C.: Women's Concerns Are Universal

One of the South Dakotans who joined the Women's March on Washington, D.C., was Suzan Nolan of Rapid City. Nolan had...

Statehouse Podcast: Wiretapping, Energy, A Preview Of Next Week

A proposal to add electronic devices to the state’s wiretapping laws probably won’t be used much in the future. The...

Lawmakers: “Expect A Busy Session Going Forward”

Statehouse legislative leaders say after a slow week of formalities, lawmakers should expect a lot more activity in...

Leadership Says Current Wiretapping Statute Hardly Used

State Republican legislative leaders say if the governor’s proposal to add electronic devices to the state’s...

Committee Investigation Into Legislator’s Sexual Contact Set For Tuesday

The legislative committee to investigate a Republican representative for sexual contact with interns will meet on...

Sculptor Of Dignity Talks Engineering

The sculptor behind the Dignity statue near Chamberlain presented a talk on the engineering details about the...

Two South Dakota Artists Work In Nasty Woman Show

Two South Dakota artists recently had their work on display in a New York exhibition. Proceeds from the sold out...

Statehouse Podcast: Vehicular Homicide, Tourism And Crackerbarrels

The State Senate will revisit a bill that failed to become law a year ago. Senate Bill 24 re-classifies Vehicular...

Legislative Cracker Barrel Format Change In Rapid City

The Rapid City Chamber of Commerce says they will change the question and answer format of their Legislative Cracker...

The Latest from NPR News

European Far-Right Politicians Talk Strategy For Upcoming Elections

Far-right politicians from across Europe, drawing breath from Brexit and Donald Trump's victory, gathered in Koblenz,...

Trump Is Yet To Sever Ties With His Business, Despite Promises To Do So, Report Says

Trump said he would surrender control of his businesses to two of his sons by Friday but ProPublica says there's no...

'Dolores' Focuses On Life Of Labor And Civil Rights Leader Dolores Huerta

Dolores Huerta was one of the co-founders of the group that became the United Farm Workers. She's continuing her...

How Does One Create A 'Fake News Masterpiece' And What Happens Next?

New York Times reporter Scott Shane talks about his recent article: "From Headline to Photograph, a Fake News...

Trump's Spiritual Adviser Talks About Relationship With President

Paula White, one of the spiritual leaders who spoke at President Donald Trump's inauguration talks about the...

Women's Marches A 'Start To Something Bigger' For Weekend's Protesters

Hundreds of thousands of women came to the Capitol for the Women's March on Washington. On Sunday, many were heading...