Trump reportedly wants to get rid of the NEA, which has revitalized communities

Last Updated by Julia Franz on

Just before President Donald Trump took office in January, the Washington, DC publication The Hill reported that the new administration was drawing up sweeping plans to cut government spending. One target? The National Endowment for the Arts, which the article says would be “eliminated entirely” under the proposed changes, along with its sister agency, the National Endowment for the Humanities.

But Dana Gioia says there would be no fiscal advantage to eliminating the NEA, a federal agency that promotes the arts and arts education. In fact, he calls the arts agency “probably one of the cheapest economic development programs the United States has.”

“That's my Trumpian argument,” he says.

Gioia is California’s poet laureate, so his support of the NEA comes as no real surprise. But more tellingly, he’s familiar with the agency’s balance books: A self-described moderate Republican, he helmed the NEA from 2003 to 2009, as an appointee of George W. Bush.

“The thing about it is that the NEA is very efficiently run nowadays,” he says. “It's got a very small staff. Most of the money goes out the door.”

In 2016, the NEA received $148 million from the federal government. That might sound like a big number, but that represented just 0.003 percent of all federal spending, according to The Washington Post. 

That federal money provides for grants to individual artists as well as arts groups, Gioia explains. “And for the arts groups, these grants are foundational because it gives them the credibility that these national panels have chosen them as one of the leading groups in the United States.”

“So the thing about it is that the NEA does not subsidize the American arts. It doesn't have enough money to subsidize anybody. But what it does do is serve as a catalyst for local groups to raise money in their own community, to serve that community in the way that the community wants to be served.”

While its funding may be a drop in the proverbial bucket, Gioia says the NEA “is reaching every state, every congressional district, every community in the United States.” He cites the agency’s Shakespeare in American Communities program, which has brought professional Shakespeare productions to approximately 4,000 towns across America.

“So, the good thing about saving the NEA right now is that there are no controversies,” he says. “And we have a tradition of bipartisan support.”

In fact, Gioia says the NEA has historically done better under Republican presidents than Democratic ones. “If you go back … to the Reagan and Bush era, and actually the early Clinton days, the endowment had, in terms of current dollars, about three times as much as it does now.”

But for Gioia, the NEA’s legacy isn’t just bipartisan — it’s economically revitalizing. He calls Charleston, South Carolina, the most impressive example in the US of using arts for economic development.

“Now, if you'd gone to Charleston 40 years ago, it was a dying community,” he says, before explaining the root of its remarkable turnaround. Charleston’s mayor talked to the composer Gian Carlo Menotti, he says, who was convinced to locate his Spoleto arts festival in the city (with NEA support).

“In the course of 40 years, the presence of this festival has transformed Charleston into the most attractive city in the southern United States,” Gioia says. “You have galleries, restaurants, you know, a tremendously positive tax base, active commercial zone and huge local employment.”

For Gioia, case studies like Charleston underscore a simple point: Supporting the arts is a sound investment.

“The fact is that when you do something that's positive, it tends to be positive in many different ways,” he says.

This article is based on an interview that aired on PRI's Studio 360.


From Studio 360 ©2016 PRI 

subscribe to sdpb email updates food and cooking banner image learning blog link living blog link news and information blog link science and technology blog link sports blog link image

The Latest From SDPB Radio News

2018 Interfaith Day At Legislative Session

In The Moment ... January 16, 2017 Show 256 Hour 1 Last week, the first ever Interfaith Day was held in the capitol...

Lutheran Social Services: Betty Oldenkamp Discusses Refugee Resettlement

In The Moment ... January 16, 2017 Show 256 Hour 2 According to the U.S. Department of State, resettling refugees...

Artist Klaire Lockheart: A Is For Apron

In The Moment ... January 16, 2017 Show 256 Hour 1 Klaire Lockheart is an artist from South Dakota. Her work...

SDSU's James Murphy Discusses Protests And National Symbols

In The Moment ... January 16, 2017 Show 256 Hour 2 Dr. James Murphy is an assistant Professor of History, Political...

Images Of The Past: General Crook And "The Horsemeat March"

In The Moment ... January 16, 2017 Show 256 Hour 2 He's one of history's often overlooked generals. This week's...

House Passes Bill To Extend LRC Comment Period

The South Dakota House of Representatives is passing a bill that gives the Legislative Research Council more time to...

Statehouse Podcast: Fraudulent Gambling, Ballot Measure Language, Data Breech

The state wants to catch and prosecute any fraudulent gamblers and cheaters in Deadwood. Larry Eliason, Executive...

Flight Club Takes Off At Roosevelt High School

The halls of Roosevelt High School in Sioux Falls are abuzz with new technology. Nathan Hofflander, adviser of the...

AG Says South Dakota Last In Country To Require Companies Disclose Personal Information Hack

The Senate Judiciary committee wants more time to consider the Attorney General’s bill that requires companies...

SDSO's Delta David Gier And Musicologist Joseph Horowitz

In The Moment ... January 12, 2017 Show 255 Hour 1 Following the success of the Music Unwound program "Dvořák and...

The Latest from NPR News

Naval Commanders In 2 Deadly Ship Collisions To Be Charged With Negligent Homicide

A total of 17 crew members were killed. The two incidents called into question the Navy's training procedures and...

Ronny Jackson: The White House Doctor Who Gave Trump A Clean Bill Of Health

The Navy rear admiral found himself in the spotlight Tuesday as he offered a folksy and authoritative update on the...

Man Ruptures His Throat By Stifling A Big Sneeze, Prompting Doctors' Warning

Not long after he suppressed a powerful sneeze, the patient's neck began swelling, crackling and popping. It was a...

Turning Soybeans Into Diesel Fuel Is Costing Us Billions

The law that requires America to turn some of its soybeans into diesel fuel for trucks has created a new industry...

Veteran Sues After Scalpel Found Inside His Body 4 Years After Surgery

"It's a level of incompetence that's almost incomprehensible," the plaintiff's lawyer tells NPR. The surgical...

DOJ Plans To Ask The Supreme Court To Intervene On DACA

Attorney General Jeff Sessions wants the high court to reverse a decision out of California forcing the government...