The Big Springs Train Robbery

Posted by Brian Gevik, Text by Gary Enright - Director - 1881 Courthouse Museum - Custer on
All Images Courtesy: 1881 Courthouse Museum, Custer

1874 Custer ExpeditionAll images courtesy: 1881 Courthouse Museum, CusterCuster Expedition - 1874

In 1877, just three years after George Custer led the Black Hills Expedition which led to the discovery of gold in the area now known as Custer, South Dakota...

train robbers image

...six outlaws stopped a Union Pacific train at the watering hole in Southwestern Nebraska known as Big Springs, just a few miles west of the town of Ogallala. What started out as a simple train hold-up, turned out to be the biggest train robbery in American history up until that time.

The robbers ordered the security car guard to open a safe….but the safe had a secure lock which couldn’t be opened until the train arrived in Cheyenne, Wyoming.

Sam Bass photoSam Bass

The gang was made up of a group of robbers who called themselves 'The Black Hills Bandits,' led by a notorious outlaw named Sam Bass of Texas.

$20 Gold Piece image

Frustrated,  four of the robbers were forcing the passengers to give up their money, while two of them stayed in the security car and accidently kicked open a small wooden box laying next to the safe. In it they found what turned out to be 60-thousand dollars worth of $20 gold coins. What started out as a robbery of ‘slim pickins’ turned out to be a ‘strike it rich’.

Meanwhile, while the robbers were fleecing the passengers, one man, Alfred Thomas Feay, a resident of the newly formed town of Custer City, Dakota Territory, was quietly stuffing over $400 in cash he carried, into his overcoat sleeves….keeping $10 out to contribute to the robbers.  The robbers never found his money.

After leaving the stalled train, the gang quietly set up a campsite close to Ogallala and stayed around for several days until someone became suspicious and identified them as the train robbers.

The gang escaped…..and broke up in to three pairs….heading in different directions.  Ultimately one of the robbers was identified as a man who escaped to Canada and was never seen again.  But all of the remaining five were eventually caught or shot by law enforcement officers over the next few weeks in Missouri and Texas.

Alfred Thomas Feay imageAlfred Thomas Feay

Oh by the way, that Custer Resident, Mr. Feay. He turned out to become a County Judge in Custer County and served in that position for the remainder of his life, serving in his office in what is now the 1881 Courthouse Museum in Custer.

Learn more about the 1881 Courthouse Museum, Custer.






"Personalities with Chuck Anderson"

Vintage radio interviews with well known and not so well known South Dakotans.

Personalities: Cheryl Ladd, Pride of Huron

She was one of Charlie's Angels, portrayed Grace Kelly in Princess Grace , and most recently played Robert Shapiro's...

Personalities: South Dakota Soldiers, Sailors, War Memorials

On July 16, 1994, Chuck Anderson visited Pierre to attend an event called "South Dakotans in WWII." It took place at...

Personalities: The Great Flood of 1993

The Great Flood of 1993 hit the American Midwest from May to September, running along the Mississippi and Missouri...

Personalities: At Home with Baxter Black

In Chuck Anderson's first interview with Baxter Black, the duo had a strong rapport. So, Chuck had to visit Baxter...

Personalities: How to Survive A Death March

When you're drafted into the military, you have a chance of being on the front lines. When you're on the front lines,...

Personalities: "Hell No, We Don't Glow!"

In the southern shadow of the Black Hills sits a small town with a small population...and a big past. Chuck Anderson...

Personalities: Being Volga German in an Anti-German World

The "Germans from Russia" story continues with Drs. Tim Kloberdanz and Harry Delker, experts in German anthropology...

Personalities: How the Volga Germans Came to America

The Dakotas are a product of Native American and northern European cultures. With a deeper look, one can see the...